Main Catch Now Serving Up Dishes to Customers

Former Southside Fish & Clams re-opens as a full-service restaurant serving seafood, steak and sushi.


Main Catch, a fine seafood restaurant, has opened its doors in the former site of Southside Fish & Clams and is ready to serve its diners. 

The Commack restaurant is still run by the same ownership, but has put a new focus on their customers. Main Catch is a full-service restaurant featuring seafood, steak and sushi on Jericho Turnpike, where Southside was previously self serve. 

"People didn't like the self-serve concept in this area. They didn't want to wait for their food or have to grab their food at the counter," said owner Tony Gambino. "With waiters and waitreses, they can sit down and have a great dining experience. 

Southside Fish & Clams closed suddenly early in 2011, putting up word via its website that it would be "temporarily closed for minor interior alterations, to better accommodate our guests."

Those who step inside might be surprised to find the dining room doesn't look radically different. It features dark mahogany woods and a nautical theme, with notable addition of a sushi bar and additional seating to bring the restaurant's capacity to 200 people. 

Gambino said many of the restaurant's changes occurred on the back end, behind kitchen doors, as the restaurant prepared to shift from self service to full service. 

"We had to restaff everyone, bring in key people. Instead of regular cooks, we brought in new chefs," Gambino said. 

Main Catch's executive chef is Mario Coiro, who previously last cooked at Marino’s on the Bay in Port Washington. He is joined by two sushi chefs who have more than 47 years combined experience. 

Robert Pence, previously owner of Oppenheimer Meats in Manhattan and a master butcher, will lead the staff of Main Catch as its general manager and have a hand in selecting the dry-aged steaks to appear on the menu. 

Main Catch's new menu will have a little bit of something for everyone, according to Gambino. Dishes include grilled swordfish ($27) and prime dry aged rib steak ($34).

Another major change at Main Catch, will be the addition of a wine list as the restaurant will begin serving alcohol. Mixed drinks and bottle service will be available from the bar. 

The restaurant is holding a soft opening, accepting dining by reservations only - no walk-ins. 

"We want to give everyone a great dining experience with no hiccups," Gambino said. "The worst thing that can happen at a new restaurant is to get slammed, and not meet expectations." 

Joe September 09, 2012 at 01:26 AM
Porterhouse steak was top notch. Also had some sushi and rolls, not as good as we hoped. Service was very poor. We will stick with Ajl 53.
KB September 17, 2012 at 08:37 PM
Just great.....after years of waiting it turns out to be just another overpriced restaurant for the neighborhood. When will owners understand that we need a local seafood place we can go to weekly, not yearly? I don't know many people that want to spend $200 a week for a family of 4. FAIL!!
Anne September 30, 2012 at 07:37 PM
Complainers, complainers they want more of an upscale restaurant for the area but don't want to pay upscale prices.. What a joke..
pbug56 September 30, 2012 at 09:09 PM
I think it's more that people want good food and decent service at reasonable prices. Those who have been there don't seem overall to feel they are getting that. In the original version of the place, the idea was good, fresh seafood with minimal though polite service at a good price. What happened there was ok food at first, not very good after a while, and generally extremely poor not very friendly service, with lots of obvious penny pinching. Yesterday I had dinner with family in Queens, an Italian place. About $25 per person, very good food for the most part, friendly attentive service. My food included extremely tender and tasty clams and very nice mussels. And it wasn't a seafood place. And it was in a high (commercial) rent area. And we felt like we had a very good value.
bob c October 07, 2012 at 02:21 PM
This place gets one star only because of it's attempt to re-invent itself. The servers try their best to make your dining a pleasure, but the food doesn't cooperate. The fried calamari was pretty close to eating rubber bands, the soup was served cold and the sole filet special must have been cooked the week before since it came to the table dry and tasteless. The decor and front of the place looks like some care went into it, but the kitchen falls decidely short. Will not venture back, for sure.....


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »