OLPH Pastor's Resignation Prompts Meeting Tuesday

Diocese holds meeting on February 28 at 7:30 p.m. at OLPH School in Lindenhurst for parishioners as they continue to react to Father Trapani's resignation announced at the beginning of February.

At the beginning of February, Father Anthony Trapani, the pastor of the -year-old in Lindenhurst, his resignation in June.

In a letter in that week's bulletin and posted on the church's website,  cited negativity directed at him about the of the as a key component in his decision to leave on .

The announcement left parishioners saddened and shocked. However, since his last day will be June 27 and the 99-year-old  is slated to a few days later, many that the timing of his arrival in 2007, and now the timing of his departure, is no coincidence.

Father Trapani's impending departure has now prompted a meeting. Representation from the Diocese of Rockville Centre will be coming to speak to parishioners tonight at the .

Information was printed in this past weekend's bulletin as part of Father Trapani's weekly letter, and posted on the church's website.

"The Episcopal Vicar (Bishop John Dunne), the area dean (Monsignor Christopher Heller) and the Vicar for Clergy Personnel (Monsignor Brian McNamara) will host an 'Open Town House Meeting' to hear the concerns and vision of the larger parish community," he wrote.

"This meeting will take place on Tuesday, February 28, at 7:30 p.m., in the school auditorium," the pastor continued. "The purpose of this...meeting is to focus on the future of the parish: Where does our parish need to go from here and what type of pastor can take us to that future?"

In this past weekend's letter Father Trapani also described the Diocese's process of picking a new pastor. (See the above PDF file.)

Since the news broke that the is one of that will close this June, Lindenhurst residents and readers of Patch have continued to be upset, and the news of Father Trapani's departure has drawn strong, mixed emotion on Patch, Facebook and Twitter.

Ahead of tonight's meeting here's what readers, residents, and parishioners have been saying: 

Christine Fritz McCarthy, on FB: "There's been a black cloud of negativity over OLPH for a long time, before Father Trapani came there. They're very unwelcoming. It's a shame how they push so many families away.

"I wish him all the best in his new parish, and hope we get someone who has open arms and an open mind. (And a PR person wouldn't hurt.)"

Ronald Rizzo, on FB: "He's just resigning after the job he was brought in to do is completed - definitely too much of a coincidence. I'd also like the real reason why he turned down the new playground equipment he school won last year in the competition!"

PegnLou Flinn Licameli, on FB: "What [kind of] job was that?! To spend all of the reserved that Monsignor [Hamilton] saved up and put us in debt? It's sad about the school, but the entire parish is a financial mess! We need someone who'll get us out of this and bring back the spirituality that had been destroyed! The attendance at mass has never been so low in all of the 20 years I've lived here!" 

Vin Boccanfuso, on Lindenhurst Patch: "Good riddance."

Robert S. Trenholm, in an e-mail to Lindenhurst Patch: "Everyone who attend the parish is upset to see him leave - except a few of those he stated in his newsletter as the cause of his decision.

"Speaking for myself, family and a few others from church, we were shocked to hear on Sunday, [February 5], when he spoke to us, informing us of his decision.

"We're aware of the standard politics and complaining of individuals that infect every facet of life and can take a toll on any person in a leadership role, but were not aware of how much or deep of an impact it took on Father Anthony.

"I don't know any or how many individuals or group that undermined or hurt Father Anthony that brought him down so much for him to give up and retreat for his own good and peace of spirit - other than the closing of the school? Like everything else, I'm sure there's more to the story than we know."

"Father Anthony has done so much for our parish, like restoring the altar and upgrading and repairing the church, [which] were needed, making hard decisions to raise the money for the repairs - successfully to my knowledge, even though it won't be complete before his departure.

"The closing of the school brought much shock and disappointment. A decision from the Diocese from my knowledge, not Father Anthony's. If anything, then that was the rug that was pulled from under him to bring him down?

"We're all hurt and will miss Father Anthony!"

More reaction about the impending closure of OLPH School and the resignation of Father Trapani could be found on the Friends of O.L.P.H. - Save Our School Facebook page. It's run by Maggie Gallagher-Lilly - a Lindenhurst native, an alum of the school and organizer of the .


Editor's Note: If you're an alum, parent of a current student or a current student, then Lindenhurst Patch would like to get your reaction to the impending OLPH school closure and your favorite memories and images of the school.

Patch would also love to hear from more parishioners about Father Trapani's announced resignation and the school's impending closure.

Share in the comments below, or on Facebook and Twitter, or e-mail barbara.loehr@patch.com.

ILoveLindy February 29, 2012 at 03:30 PM
PLEASE SAVE OLPH CHURCH- In 2007, leaders from the Diocese of Rockville Centre held a meeting with O.L.P.H. parishioners to allow them to voice their requests for the pastor who would replace Monsignor Hamilton. Overwhelmingly, the parishioners expressed that the new pastor support the school. Under new pastor Trapani's leadership, the following happened: Monsignor Hamilton's approx 150 thousand $ from successful fund raising campain disappeared, fund raising programs were completely shut down, people who had worked and volunteered for years in the church on fund raising were fired, Trapani told the school they couldn't accept the playground that the school had won in a national competition, panicked parents and fund raisers wrote letters to Bishop Murphy asking him to intervene. The letters were ignored, meanwhile, he spent gobs of money on "Restoring God's Glory" Father Trapani announces his resignation and cruelly places blame on parishioners who desperately tried to save the 100 year old school. Anyone who doesn't see what is happening here is uninformed or completely out of touch. Goodbye church.
Jeannie Smith February 29, 2012 at 10:17 PM
During rehearsals for both Confirmation and Communion, we were repeatedly told that dropping the host when receiving communion was a mortal sin and that person would go to hell - so please be careful. My son is in special education and is not always the most coordinated child. I am terrified he will one day drop it, so I don't have him receive. I think these stories are very sad and instead of the church being a welcoming place in these difficult times, it has become another source of stress and feeling condemned when you go.
vin boccanfuso March 01, 2012 at 03:26 PM
couldnt agree with all of you more.
Proud Lindy Mom of 2 April 22, 2012 at 03:49 AM
Jeannie - sorry if you were misinformed, but dropping the blessed sacrament is not a mortal sin. Please bring your child back to church, OLPH or another. When a consecrated host is dropped it must be picked up eaten (the priest usually does that) or dissolve it in holy water. Again, it isn't a mortal sin.
Debbie B April 22, 2012 at 02:17 PM
Dear Jeannie, I was a Catechism teacher (volunteer) for 9 years. Although all teachers are given the tools needed to correctly school the children, I have heard stories of teachers verbalizing to the children what is not church teaching. This would be one of those times. Don't feel shy about inquiring whether what was said is correct and you can mention who said it so this misinformation ceases to be taught.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »