Steak/Sushi Restaurant Rises at Former Boulder Creek Site

Insignia Prime Steak and Sushi is scheduled to open on Route 347 at the end of 2011.

Months of construction at the former site of Boulder Creek Restaurant on Nesconset Highway and Mount Pleasant Road has drawn local residents' interest and speculation on what's coming next. The answer: steak and sushi.

Work is underway on Insignia Prime Steak and Sushi, an upscale steakhouse whose owners believe they can find success where Boulder Creek failed.

"They are two extremely different steakhouse styles," said Ronald Johnston, general manager of Insignia. "This is pretty much like nothing Long Island has ever seen."

Boulder Creek, a Western-inspired, mountain lodge-themed chain restaurant did "extremely well" at the Route 347 location after it first opened for business in 1999, Johnston said. Over time, the Smithtown restaurant "just didn't pan out" according to Arthur Viana, one of Insignia's owners, who did not elaborate. 

The chain closed the Smithtown location about four years ago, as well as many of its other locations in the region. Boulder Creek still has four restaurants on Long Island in Bay Shore, Franklin Square, Hicksville and Riverhead.

Boulder Creek's owners, restauranteurs Anthony Scotto and Mario Sbarro, ended their business partnership after it closed, and the building on Route 347 sat vacant until June 2011, when construction began on the new restaurant. Scotto remains an owner with three new partners, including Viana. 

Viana said Insignia will be a high-end eatery and bar with an elaborate menu and wine selection featuring more than 500 labels. It will serve dinner seven days a week and offer catering, he said. One of its features will be a large bar designed to seat at least 35 people, separated from the dining area.

The building occupies the same footprint as the former Boulder Creek, but has been modified extensively. Insignia will have a lounge area and a garden area with outdoor seating, Johnston said, with a sushi bar in the main dining room. A complete valet parking service will be offered, he added.

Belvedere Construction of East Setauket is handling the construction and renovations of Insigna, which are on schedule to be finished in the beginning of November.

The restaurant’s opening is not set, but is expected to be in late November or early December, according to Viana.

Candyee November 11, 2011 at 08:01 PM
on occasion , like a birthday or such eaten at a high end restaurant.. I have only eaten at Paces may be 4 times in 31 yrs .... YES , I am a 10!! Aren't you ?? You should consider yourself a 10... You are entilted to spend you money any way you see fit..If that is what you want then well , enjoy . May be treat a family who cannot afford to go there , You know, the ones who eat in Friendly's ? Or use the discount coupons so they can go out once in awhile . That is the point I am saying , most cannot never afford to eat in places like that.,,, I donate my time to help these families ,, There are so many needy , .. So while you are spoling yourself , think of them ...
Sara Walsh (Editor) November 11, 2011 at 09:08 PM
Please note that Patch's policy does not allow name calling or flaming. Let's please keep the conversation about the Insignia, the incoming sushi/steakhouse. - Sara Walsh, Hauppauge Patch Editor.
Carolyn November 11, 2011 at 09:33 PM
Can't wait for the opening !! Camille- I'll toast my first drink to you, sorry you wont be there.
Candyee November 11, 2011 at 09:43 PM
Toast to the needy people in the area...
Candyee November 12, 2011 at 05:31 PM
Thank you , Cindy . There are so that need help , food, clothes , many of our Vets who have no jobs , no place to live , need a helping hand and food, and we "badly need an '"over the top" restaurant? That is what got me upset .I donate time and cook food ( I have won awards for my cooking ) can afford to eat there, but I won't. I believe in Karma, everyone will get there just reward .
Carolyn November 13, 2011 at 08:46 PM
I do help in many ways but I'm not going to donate an expense dinner to them. I still feel Insignia is a great place Smithtown will have to enjoy. If you wanted a food pantry or soup kitchen Smithtown isnt the place for it. As for Cindy, karma will absolutely come to those who wish harm on others so thank you Camille for reminding us of that. Insignia is going to be a great place and i'm sure will create alot of memories shared there. I'm also sure they will give away a ton of gift cards to schools or organizations raffling or fund raising. Other restaurants always have and Friendlys wasnt one of them.
Candyee November 13, 2011 at 09:39 PM
I would hope they would help out people in need. Any left over bakery, food , etc should be donated to the needy. There are many restaurants that throw out , awful .I don t know what Friendly's does, I hope they reconsider. You are right, Smithtown is not the place for a soup kitchen , but the churches in area have pantries , hard to keep them stocked these days . I really don t eat in Friendlys ,but I know of families that do there, lucky they can do that occasional .. My kids well grown ,,, have grandkids , Don t have to do that anymore .
Luanne November 13, 2011 at 10:32 PM
I'm curious to see how well it does. I will check it out but there are so many place to go--it'll have to be really good for me to drive 12 miles!! I tend to stay local--lots of good restaurants on the south shore to frequent.
Candyee November 13, 2011 at 11:35 PM
You are aware that Blackstones in Huntington , is also a Scotto restaurant .There are many good places to go ..You are right .
Smithtown Rez November 14, 2011 at 06:16 PM
Wow...so an entreprenuer takes over an abandoned commercial location to make a go of it and will let capitalism decide if he is successful, but this thread devolves into negative commentary about it not being for families of lesser means, or they better donate to local food pantries, etc. Did I miss the part where this place bulldozed a shelter for needy families and/or stole food off of a child's plate? Let's wish for a successful business that will add to the tax base. This helps all of Smithtown. If you want to help in the local community volunteer your time and means. I do. And I also go to Friendly's AND higher end restaurants. sheesh...
Candyee November 14, 2011 at 06:33 PM
.. Mr Scotto was part owner of Boulder Creek ,The property has been up for sale since he and Mr Sbarro parted ways. I am assuming he could not sell it for the price he was asking . Decieded Smithtown needs an "upscale " restaurant .He has been paying taxes on the property.. Whatever. BTW , I DO volunteer for less fortunate here in area. You would be amazed how many there are in oiur 'upscale" neighborhood. I hope you do same .It may be your neighbors who are to proud to come foward. Smithtown having a shelter? Never would happen . Enjoy the new place !
Candyee November 14, 2011 at 06:37 PM
@ Smithtown Rez. There are many issues we do agree on . I have been reading your letters on different topics for awhile.
Joel Blitzer November 14, 2011 at 09:22 PM
Sign up and share with friends to receive a $25 Dining Certificate. All you have to do is copy the unique link provided after sign up to your Facebook page and tell 2 friends to return to the page and enter your unique code. Once your two friends sign up, you unlock your $25 dining card good at Rare650, Blackstone Steakhouse or Insignia. Sharing is Caring, so start now, because you only have 3 weeks to share! Use this special link http://bit.ly/w4Kzqb
Candyee November 14, 2011 at 09:31 PM
Thank you Joel , for the info . I already signed up and fowarded to a few friends who have not yet accepted . If I am able to get $25, it will be given to a friend who is in need.
Jim R. November 15, 2011 at 06:58 PM
High end! We need more high end establishments on LI. Only the rich should be able to eat out on LI!
Candyee November 15, 2011 at 07:23 PM
Joel ...NO ONE accepted the invites I sent so I am not able to get a $25 food card . Still locked ..I sent out the most I was able to .. I did get some e mails from a few ,telling me never would they go there .Everyone is a professional I sent to . The response I got was "overpriced" !!
Joel Blitzer November 16, 2011 at 04:11 PM
New steakhouse feeds cancer research by Michael H. Samuels Published: November 16, 2011 Tags: Anthony Scotto, Cancer research, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Insignia Steakhouse, Long Island To celebrate the grand opening of a Smithtown steakhouse, its owner is donating half of first week sales to cancer research at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. Anthony Scotto, the proprietor of several Long Island restaurants including Blackstone in Melville and Rare650 in Syosset, will open his newest restaurant called Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi at 610 Nesconset Highway at the end of the month. “We want to give back to the Long Island community that honors us with their patronage,” Scotto said in a statement. “I can think of no better way than to support Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory’s innovative research program which is committed to improving the diagnosis and treatment of all major forms of cancer.”
We Heart Long Island December 02, 2011 at 12:49 PM
Uh... HELLOooooo.... this is NOT a socialist country... no one has to "share" their wealth. Nor feel guilty for working hard to earn their salary and be able to enjoy a good dinner at a high end restaurant - that they have earned,,,This is America. I feel bad that you seem so bitter, Camille.
Jim R. December 05, 2011 at 01:38 AM
You're missing the point "We Heart...". Their are plenty of people and families on LI that just want to go out and have a good meal w/out paying exorbitant prices. I do fairly well, but most of these "high end" places serve garbage. They just jack up the prices to keep out the goombah trash that lives here.
Candyee December 05, 2011 at 03:11 PM
We Heart. I am NOT bitter at all .If helping out unfortunate people that are down on there luck is bad , then I am guilty . You are right,no one has to share there wealth, but it is rewarding to help out those who have lost jobs,homes, etc.Very rewarding to help out others . I have a wonderful life .I chose to help whom I can . A $100 plus meal for 2 people is excessive. That $100 can feed a family for a week or so.You sound greedy , we heart, and I feel bad for you, We heart Long Island .The seven deadly sins is alive and well , I see. As you savor your meal , think about others here on LI that were in the same postion as you are at one time. It may be you someday . Namaste .
Candyee December 05, 2011 at 03:13 PM
Grammar typo ..The seven deadly ARE alive and well. Excuse my error.
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:04 AM
Camille - You are a communist. Who are you to say what is excssive. My bet is that you are overweight ...that is excesive. Move to Russia and give your money to those commies
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:13 AM
so dont go there.....You really hate successful people. Could it be because you are a lazy loser?
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:15 AM
yea Jim - - you must be one of those cheap tippers.... such a loser if you cant afford to go out - - -=stay home
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:19 AM
you are such an opinionated old broad. the place is great . . .lets face it - - not for U
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:20 AM
Such a liberal cry baby So stay home Let the rest of us enjoy our lives and the fruits of our labor U r such a loser
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:21 AM
so pathetic...your kind...always looking for a handout get a job and earn it
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:24 AM
oh yea - credit cards are for people who are credit worthy . . . not U
rgg December 09, 2011 at 02:28 AM
Hey Camille - -What was your highets grade in school... sounds like u are very uneducated. BAD GRAMMAR 2
Candyee December 09, 2011 at 03:03 AM
rgg . What a moron you are . What is highets ? U is not a word . Please explain "bad grammar 2" .Do you mean two? I am a retired teacher. I bet you are a high school drop out , have no job and live off Mommy and Daddy , By the way , I was not speaking to you , so mind your own business , You also cannot spell . Excssive , excesive . did you mean excessive ? Commies, overweight , move to Russia . Really . What idiotic things to say . You are bullying me . You can spend your money wherever you please . I don't really care as I am entilted to spend mine where I wish . You need to learn proper English and to spell correctly.Do you speak the same way you type? Did you bully everyone is school and do you still bully everyone around you ? Your insecurities are showing .


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something